Read the original article here.

---

Understanding Open-Source Hardware: Building Blocks for the "Lost Art"

In an era where computers often feel like sealed black boxes, understanding the fundamental layers of hardware can seem like a "lost art." Open-source hardware offers a powerful way to reclaim this knowledge. By making designs, schematics, and documentation freely available, it empowers individuals to understand, modify, and even build physical technology from the ground up. This resource explores what open-source hardware is, its history, its various forms, and its potential impact on learning and building technology.

What is Open-Source Hardware?

Open-source hardware (OSH) refers to the design and sharing of physical technology under principles similar to open-source software. It's part of a broader "open-design movement" that promotes collaboration, transparency, and free access to knowledge.

Open-Source Hardware (OSH or OSHW): Physical technology whose design information (schematics, bills of materials, layout data, source code, etc.) is made publicly available under licenses that allow users to study, modify, distribute, and build the hardware.

Free and Open-Source Hardware (FOSH): A term sometimes used to emphasize both the "open" aspect (transparent, easily accessible design) and the "free" aspect (freedom to use, modify, and share the design).

Just as open-source software (FOSS - Free and Open-Source Software) provides the source code for programs, OSH provides the "source code" for physical devices. This can include:

• Mechanical drawings: Detailed plans for physical parts and assemblies.
• Schematics: Diagrams showing the electrical connections within a circuit.
• Bills of Materials (BOMs): Lists of all components needed to build the hardware.
• PCB layout data: Files used to manufacture printed circuit boards (the green boards with components).
• HDL source code: Code used to describe digital circuits for programmable chips.
• Integrated circuit layout data: Detailed designs for manufacturing custom silicon chips.
• Software/Firmware: Code that runs on the hardware, often also released under open licenses to complement the hardware design.

The core idea is transparency and collaboration. Sharing designs allows others to learn, identify errors, suggest improvements, and build upon existing work, leading to faster innovation and potentially better quality.

OSH and the "Lost Art"

For someone interested in the "lost art" of building computers, OSH is invaluable. Traditional hardware often comes with proprietary designs locked away by manufacturers. Understanding how a component works, why certain parts are used, or how to replicate it is difficult without the underlying blueprints.

OSH provides these blueprints. Want to understand how a basic microcontroller board works? An OSH design like Arduino provides the full schematic and layout. Interested in the logic inside a CPU? Projects like RISC-V and OpenCores offer open instruction sets and reusable digital logic designs (IP Cores) that you can study and even implement yourself using tools like FPGAs.

Proprietary Hardware: Hardware whose design details are kept secret by the manufacturer. This makes it difficult or impossible for others to fully understand, modify, or replicate the device.

OSH breaks down these barriers, enabling:

• Deeper Understanding: By examining the design files, you can see exactly how components are connected and why.
• Modification and Customization: You can adapt existing designs to your specific needs, rather than being limited to off-the-shelf products.
• Education and Learning: OSH provides concrete, real-world examples for learning electronics, digital design, mechanics, and more.
• Repair and Longevity: With open designs, repairing hardware becomes more feasible, extending its lifespan.
• Building from Fundamentals: You can potentially build complex systems by combining simpler, open-source modules.

A Brief History of Open-Source Hardware

While the term gained prominence later, early ideas around open hardware emerged alongside the open-source software movement.

• Late 1990s: Bruce Perens, a key figure in open-source software, launched an "Open Hardware Certification Program." Other initiatives like the Open Hardware Specification Project (OHSpec) and the Open Design Foundation (ODF) also appeared, attempting to define and promote open principles for hardware. FreeIO, founded by Diehl Martin, released hardware designs under the GNU GPL, advocating "four freedoms" similar to free software.
• Mid-2000s: A resurgence of interest occurred with the rise of significant projects and companies. RepRap brought 3D printing into the open-source world, allowing users to build machines that could potentially "replicate" themselves. Arduino popularized open-source electronics prototyping, making it accessible to hobbyists and educators. Companies like Adafruit and SparkFun built businesses around selling open-source electronic components and kits. OpenCores provided a library of reusable digital circuit designs.
• Late 2000s/Early 2010s: The need for dedicated open hardware licenses became clear. The TAPR Open Hardware License was one of the first. Organizations like the Open Hardware Foundation (OHF) and later the Open Source Hardware Association (OSHWA) were established to promote and define OSH principles. CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research, released its own CERN Open Hardware License (OHL) to facilitate sharing designs within the scientific community.
• 2010s onwards: The "Open Hardware Definition" was developed, consolidating principles. The RISC-V instruction set architecture emerged as a major open standard for chip design. Academic journals like HardwareX and the Journal of Open Hardware were launched, fostering research and documentation standards for OSH. Crowdfunding became a popular way to fund OSH projects.

This history shows a progression from initial ideas to established projects, organizations, and licensing frameworks, indicating the growing maturity and impact of the OSH movement.

Forms of Open-Source Hardware

While the term "hardware" in OSH initially contrasted with software, it has expanded to encompass a wide range of physical artifacts.

Hardware (in OSH context): Refers broadly to any tangible physical product, machine, device, or physical thing, encompassing electronics, mechanical systems, and even larger structures.

Different categories of OSH are relevant depending on what aspect of "building a computer from scratch" you're focusing on:

Electronics

This is perhaps the most common form of OSH. It involves making the designs for electronic circuits and devices openly available.

• Examples: Arduino microcontrollers, various sensor boards, power supplies, interfaces (USB, Ethernet adapters).
• Relevance to "Building a Computer": Electronics are the core components of any computer. Understanding the schematics and layouts of OSH electronics helps you grasp how processors interact with memory, peripherals, and the outside world. You can build your own interface boards, custom controllers, or power solutions by following open designs.
• How it works: Designs are shared as CAD (Computer-Aided Design) files, which can be sent directly to manufacturers to produce Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs). Component lists (BOMs) guide you on purchasing parts, which you can then assemble (often requiring soldering).

Chip Design (Semiconductor)

This involves making the designs for integrated circuits (chips) open. This is a more advanced area but crucial for truly understanding the heart of a computer.

• Examples: RISC-V (an open instruction set architecture), OpenRISC (an open processor design), OpenCores (a library of reusable digital logic blocks).
• Relevance to "Building a Computer": This relates directly to designing the CPU, memory controllers, and other complex logic on a chip. Studying open chip designs allows you to see how digital logic is implemented at the silicon level. While fabricating your own custom chip is complex and expensive, you can implement and test these designs using Field-Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs).
• How it works: Designs are described using Hardware Description Languages (HDLs). These language descriptions (like VHDL or Verilog) are the "source code" for chips. These descriptions can be loaded onto FPGAs for prototyping or sent to specialized foundries for Application-Specific Integrated Circuit (ASIC) fabrication.

Hardware Description Language (HDL): A programming language used to describe the structure, design, and operation of electronic circuits, particularly digital logic circuits. Examples include VHDL and Verilog.

Field-Programmable Gate Array (FPGA): An integrated circuit designed to be configured by a customer or designer after manufacturing. FPGAs contain programmable logic blocks and programmable interconnects that can be wired together using HDL code to implement complex digital circuits. Useful for prototyping chip designs.

Application-Specific Integrated Circuit (ASIC): A custom-designed integrated circuit manufactured for a specific use or application, in contrast to general-purpose processors. ASICs are typically more performant and power-efficient for their specific task but are expensive to design and manufacture.

Semiconductor Intellectual Property (IP) Core: A reusable block of logic or circuitry designed for inclusion in a larger integrated circuit design. OpenCores provides a library of such open-source IP Cores (e.g., processor cores, memory controllers, peripheral interfaces).

Mechanics

This form focuses on the physical, non-electronic parts of hardware.

• Examples: OpenBeam (modular structural system), WikiHouse (open designs for houses), physical enclosures, robotics arms, machine tool frames.
• Relevance to "Building a Computer": Computers need physical enclosures (cases). Peripherals like keyboards, mice, and printers involve mechanical parts. Understanding open mechanical designs helps in building custom housings or even designing physical interfaces for your computer project.

Mechatronics

Many complex OSH projects combine electronics and mechanics, often with software control.

• Examples: 3D printers (RepRap, Prusa), laser cutters (Lasersaur), robotics platforms, automated lab equipment.
• Relevance to "Building a Computer": While not directly building the computer's core, mechatronics is essential for the tools used in hardware development (like 3D printers for rapid prototyping) and for peripherals that interact with the physical world. A robotics project, for example, is a complex system combining open-source hardware (motors, sensors, controllers) and open-source software.

Robotics

A specific area of mechatronics that combines open hardware with AI and control software.

• Relevance to "Building a Computer": Robotics often involves using embedded computers or microcontrollers (like Arduino or Raspberry Pi, which have significant OSH aspects) to control motors, read sensors, and execute tasks. Studying open robotics projects provides examples of integrating computing hardware with complex physical systems.

These different forms show that OSH isn't just about circuit boards; it encompasses any physical technology where the design is shared, providing diverse avenues for learning and building.

Development and Challenges

Developing OSH shares similarities with OSS but also has unique challenges.

Open Design / Open Source Product Development: The process of designing and developing physical products (including hardware) in a collaborative, transparent manner, often involving distributed communities and sharing of design data under open licenses.

• Tangible Outputs & Cost: Unlike software, hardware results in physical objects. Prototyping, manufacturing, and distributing physical hardware incurs costs ("free as in speech, not as in beer"). This means OSH projects often require funding (e.g., through crowdfunding) or rely on businesses that sell the manufactured OSH products while keeping the designs open.
• Documentation: Clear and detailed documentation is even more critical for hardware than software. Users need precise instructions, component lists, assembly guides, and calibration procedures to replicate or modify hardware reliably. Poor documentation is a major barrier.
• Tools: Hardware design requires specific software tools (CAD, PCB layout, HDL compilers), which may be proprietary or require significant learning curves. While open-source design tools exist, they are not always as mature as commercial options.
• Collaboration: Managing contributions to a physical design is different from managing code. Version control for CAD files or physical layouts can be more complex than for text-based code. Ensuring compatibility between modified designs can also be challenging.
• Manufacturing: While sharing design files is easy, manufacturing requires physical infrastructure (PCB fabrication, machining, 3D printing). The rise of accessible manufacturing services and desktop fabrication tools (like 3D printers) has significantly aided OSH development.

Despite these challenges, the OSH community is developing practices and tools to facilitate collaboration. Initiatives promoting better documentation standards and exploring sustainable funding models are key to its continued growth. Scientific communities are major drivers, using OSH to create affordable, customizable lab equipment.

Licensing Open-Source Hardware

Licensing is crucial for defining how open hardware designs can be used, modified, and shared. While some early projects used software licenses (like GPL), the legal basis for hardware differs significantly, primarily relying on patent law rather than copyright.

Copyleft License: A type of license (like the GNU GPL or CERN OHL) that requires derivatives (modifications or products built from the design) to also be released under the same or a compatible license. This ensures that improvements and subsequent designs remain open.

Permissive License: A type of license (like MIT or BSD) that allows users to freely use, modify, and distribute the design, often without requiring derivative works to be open-sourced.

Key points about OSH licensing:

• Patent vs. Copyright: Software licenses typically rely on copyright to control the distribution of source code. Hardware designs, especially the implementation of an idea, are often protected by patents. OSH licenses must address both the distribution of design documents (copyright) and the actual use or manufacture of the device described by the design (patent). Many OSH licenses include clauses preventing users from patenting the design they received or suing others who use the original OSH design.
• Hardware-Specific Licenses: Licenses like the TAPR Open Hardware License and the CERN Open Hardware License were created specifically for hardware, addressing the interplay between design files, physical manufacturing, and intellectual property rights like patents.
• Recommended Licenses: The Open Source Hardware Association (OSHWA) recommends a set of licenses, including both hardware-specific ones (CERN OHL, TAPR OHL) and adapted software/creative commons licenses (GPL, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike, MIT, BSD, Creative Commons Attribution).

Choosing an appropriate license ensures that the intentions of the designer regarding use, modification, and sharing are legally protected and understood by the community.

Business Models and Ecosystem

The OSH movement is supported by various business models:

• Selling Kits and Assembled Hardware: Companies like Adafruit and SparkFun build businesses around selling components, kits, and pre-assembled versions of open-source designs (often their own). The designs remain open, allowing others to replicate, but the convenience of purchasing from these vendors supports their operations.
• Providing Manufacturing Services: Companies that offer PCB fabrication, 3D printing, or machining services benefit from OSH by manufacturing products designed by others.
• Crowdfunding: Many OSH projects rely on platforms like Kickstarter or Indiegogo to raise funds for initial development, prototyping, and manufacturing runs.
• Support and Consulting: Businesses can offer support, customization, or consulting services based on open-source hardware designs.
• "Open Core" Models: Some companies might keep certain complex or high-value parts proprietary while making core components or interfaces open. (This is less purely "open source" but a hybrid model seen in the industry).
• Academic and Research Funding: Universities and research institutions fund OSH development, particularly for scientific instruments, as it reduces costs and promotes reproducibility.

The ecosystem includes vendors selling components, manufacturers producing boards or parts, online repositories for sharing designs, community forums for collaboration, and educational initiatives. This robust ecosystem makes it easier for individuals to engage with OSH.

Reception and Impact

The reception of OSH has evolved. Initially met with skepticism by some figures in the free software movement, its importance is now more widely recognized.

• Ethical and Social Impact: Proponents argue that OSH has significant ethical implications, particularly for sustainable development and research. Open designs for tools, medical equipment, and appropriate technology can empower communities and reduce reliance on expensive, proprietary solutions. This aligns with the "lost art" idea by fostering self-reliance and local capacity building.
• Academic Growth: OSH has become a recognized field of study. Academic journals dedicated to OSH provide platforms for researchers to publish and review open designs, establishing standards for documentation and reproducibility. This validation helps integrate OSH into formal education.
• Innovation: By lowering the barriers to entry and enabling collaboration, OSH can accelerate innovation in various fields, from robotics to scientific instrumentation.
• Challenges and Debates: Discussions continue regarding defining "open" for hardware, the effectiveness of different licenses, ensuring sustainability for projects, and navigating the tension between community ideals and commercial realities.

Ultimately, open-source hardware provides a crucial pathway for anyone wishing to delve deeper into the mechanics and electronics of physical technology. It offers the blueprints and a collaborative community spirit necessary to understand and potentially revive the fundamental skills involved in building and maintaining complex systems like computers. By exploring OSH projects, you can move beyond being just a user of technology to becoming an informed modifier and creator.